By Rev Fr Paulinus Ikechukwu Ogara
Nigeria’s security landscape has been marred by incessant kidnappings, terrorist activities, and other violent crimes. The country’s centralised policing system has not been able to effectively respond to localised security concerns. This is largely due to the fact that the federal police are overstretched and lack the necessary resources and manpower to respond effectively to security challenges across the country. Establishing state police in Nigeria is therefore seen as crucial as it will provide localized solutions needed for containing the situation.
Meaning of State Police
State police refers to the police forces that operate at the state level under the control of individual state governments. State police are responsible for enforcing state laws, providing traffic enforcement on state highways, and assisting local law enforcement agencies when needed.
Why We Need State Police
Establishing state police has several benefits that could make a substantial difference in the fight against crimes in Nigeria. Some of these benefits include:
Local Knowledge and Enhanced Community Policing: State police would be more familiar with the local communities, their cultures, and the dynamics of crime in their respective states, allowing for more effective community policing and better relationships between law enforcement and citizens. For instance, in the Niger Delta region, state police officers familiar with the local terrain and communities can more effectively address security challenges related to oil bunkering and pipeline vandalism.
Faster Response: With state police, delay in response to emergencies and crimes can be significantly reduced. They can respond more quickly and effectively to incidents and emergencies without having to wait for instructions from Abuja before responding to a security threat, preventing escalation and reducing harm to citizens, reducing the time it takes for federal police to arrive from Abuja.
Tailored Law Enforcement: Different states in Nigeria face varying security challenges. State police forces can tailor their strategies and operations to address specific threats, making law enforcement more effective and efficient.
Relief for Federal Police: In addition, state police forces would help reduce the burden on the federal police. The Nigeria Police Force is currently stretched thin, trying to cover security needs across the entire country. With state police in places, the federal police will then focus on national security challenges, such as terrorism and cross-border crimes, while the state police deal with local security concerns.
Accountability and Oversight: State police can be more accountable to the communities they serve. Local governments and citizens can have more oversight over police activities, leading to increased transparency and trust, reducing the risk of human rights abuses and increasing transparency.
Job Creation and Empowerment: Establishing state police forces can create jobs and empower local communities. This can have positive socioeconomic impacts, particularly in areas with high levels of unemployment and poverty.
Improved Intelligence Gathering: State police can tap into local knowledge-gather intelligence more effectively at the grassroots level, leading to better-informed decision-making and proactive crime prevention measures, helping to prevent and investigate crimes more effectively.
Flexibility and Adaptability: State police forces can quickly adapt to changing security situations and employ strategies that are best suited to local conditions, enhancing their ability to maintain law and order.
Enhanced Interagency Cooperation: Collaboration between state police, federal police, and other security agencies can be improved with state police forces, leading to more coordinated efforts in combating crime.
Issues, Concerns and Criticisms
Despite its potential benefits, the issue of state police also raises several issues and concerns which bother on the risks and challenges associated with this approach.
Financial Burden: One of the primary concerns about state police is the significant financial burden it would place on states. Establishing and maintaining a state police force would require substantial funding and resources, which could be a challenge for many states. This could lead to a situation where some states are unable to effectively fund their police forces, resulting in inadequate security provision and potentially exacerbating existing security challenges. Furthermore, the financial burden of state policing could also lead to a situation where states are forced to divert resources away from other essential public services, such as healthcare and education, in order to fund their police forces.
Risk of Politicization: Another concern is the risk of politicization. There is a danger that state police forces could be used as tools for political repression, with governors or state governments using them to suppress opposition or maintain power. This could undermine the democratic process and lead to a situation where citizens are unable to freely exercise their rights. For example, state police could be used to intimidate or harass opposition candidates, or to suppress peaceful protests and demonstrations. This would be a clear abuse of power and a threat to democracy.
Potential for Abuse of Power: The potential for abuse of power is also a significant concern when it comes to the issue of state police. There is a risk that state governors could use state police forces to engage in human rights violations, such as arbitrary arrests, torture, and extrajudicial killings. This could lead to a situation where citizens are unable to trust the police or feel safe in their presence. Furthermore, the abuse of power by state police could also undermine the rule of law and lead to a breakdown in social order.
Coordination Challenges: Another challenge is the need for coordination with federal police and other security agencies. This could be a complex and challenging process, requiring significant resources and infrastructure. There is a risk that state police forces could operate in isolation from federal agencies, leading to confusion and inefficiency in law enforcement. For example, state police may not have access to federal databases or intelligence, which could hinder their ability to effectively investigate and prosecute crimes.
Training and Capacity Building: Finally, state police forces would require significant training and capacity building to ensure they are effective and professional. This could be a challenge, particularly in states with limited resources and infrastructure. There is a risk that state police forces could be poorly trained and equipped. This could lead to a situation where they are unable to effectively respond to security challenges. Furthermore, the lack of training and capacity building could also lead to human rights violations and abuse of power.
Weighing the Arguments on Both Sides
The issue of state police is a subject of much controversy. Proponents argue that state police would allow for more localized and effective law enforcement, while critics raise concerns about potential misuse of power, inequality, and lack of adequate training and funding. The controversy highlights the need for careful consideration and thorough discussion.
To address these concerns, several key steps can be taken. Establishing clear guidelines and oversight mechanisms can help mitigate the risk of abuse of power by state governors. Implementing robust training programs and funding allocations can ensure that state police forces are adequately equipped to handle their responsibilities.
Ultimately, the decision to establish state police forces in Nigeria should be based on a thorough analysis of the benefits and drawbacks, as well as a commitment to ensuring that any new policing arrangement is effective, professional, and accountable to the publice.
Conclusion
Overall, as Nigeria continues to grapple with its security challenges, it is essential to consider establishing state police to improve public safety and security. Their knowledge of the peculiarities of the respective states and tailored approach to the dynamics of crime in them make it a compelling option in the fight against insecurity. Today, with Nigeria’s insecurity crisis at boiling point, the need for state policing has become more than urgent.
Comment here